
BAGUIO CITY, Philippines — Various experts have offered an alternative view on the US-led Pax Silica initiative, seeing the partnership as an opportunity for Philippine industries despite persistent protests against the country’s participation.
The undertaking, which seeks to lessen reliance on China for minerals critical to the global supply chain that supports the artificial intelligence (AI) revolution, should be viewed as a potential market for the country, according to geologist Graciano Yumul.
“If you believe in all the projections, the mining super cycle will be good up to the middle of the 2030s. So for the local mining industry, this is good for the simple reason that all of these megatrend issues are actually making sure that demands are high and the supply is actually limited,” Yumul, a published scholar who is president and CEO of the Cordillera Exploration Co. Inc., told the Mining Industry Symposium here on Thursday.
READ: No Pax Silica signing during Trump’s Manila visit – Marcos, Lipton
“Based on all the projections [of analysts like] JPMorganChase, [extracting] copper, nickel, gold, lithium, rare earth minerals, tungsten, uranium and graphite carbon will be the way to go [for the country’s mining industry],” he also said.
Environmental and indigenous rights advocates as well as university students have protested against the Philippines’ joining the alliance in April. While no deal has been finalized yet with the United States, New Clark City in Tarlac has reserved a 1,620-hectare property to host an AI chip-building hub under Pax Silica, using critical elements mined from the so-called Mindanao Mining Corridor.
READ: Peasant group vows to intensify campaign against Pax Silica
Lawyer Marjorie Ramos Samaniego, governor of the Board of Investments, said market opportunities for extracting critical minerals have reinforced the government’s drive toward the country’s industrialization, as well as encouraged mining giants to explore and invest in refining minerals domestically.
At present, top mining firms still export raw mineral ore to countries that can process them.
“While our mineral resources are finite, the capabilities that we can build from them do not have to be … Minerals may be where the story begins but minerals should not be where the story ends for the Philippines,” Samaniego said.
“Our ambition is to move from minerals to manufacturing, and from manufacturing to innovation … [and connect] our mineral wealth with the industries of the future,” she added.
Geopolitical context
Yumul, however, said the Philippines must join Pax Silica with a clear eye about the geopolitics it will be embroiled in, and know exactly how the country’s sovereign interests should be asserted.
All US decisions are guided by the “America First” policy of its current president, Donald Trump, while many scholars believe that China’s aspiration is to be the leader of the world economy, which was set in motion by its late paramount leader, Deng Xiaoping, in the late 1980s, he noted.
Yumul said there has been “a change of landscape” dating back to 2023 when the aspiration for critical minerals “was in the context of the green transition, which is [in response to] climate change, and with digital transformation, that is now digital acceleration.”
He pointed out that when Ukraine began repulsing a Russian invasion four years ago, and after America waged war on Iran in February, “the major trigger of critical mineral supply would not actually be clean energy [nor] energy transition, but military defense at this point in time.”
“Learn from Ukraine,” he said.
Ukraine, according to him, inexplicably became a proxy in the duel between superpowers—Russia, the United States and European countries belonging to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization or Nato.
The Philippines, by comparison, is in the middle of an economic conflict between the United States and China, said Yumul. “There has got to be a Philippine aspiration to play toe-to-toe with these two powers,” he said.
He stressed that a “power transition among nations, proxy wars and pawn avoidance must be understood” as the country is rendered vulnerable due to its internal concerns like a weakening economy, steep inflation, soaring food and fuel prices and the current very strong El Niño.
“Seventy percent of our export goes to China. But right now, at this point in time, we’re heavily hedging toward the US side,” he said.
Shifting tide
But the Philippines has to act quickly, he said, because critical minerals “would only be critical as long as there is economic need.”
Battery technology, for instance, has moved forward from nickel cobalt to lithium manganese, and now to the much cheaper sodium chloride, Yumul said.
Anne Karla Navarro, supervising geologist of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau, said critical minerals are not country-specific so the Philippines’ current list of critical minerals is constantly being reviewed to address emerging needs.
An inventory is also underway to determine the industry players who will be commissioned for a Pax Silica project.
Yumul said the Philippines must also solve one of its biggest hurdles in joining the initiative and pursuing industrialization—the cost of electricity.
“The economics [for a development of downstream mineral processing trade] now is not good” because the country has the second-highest electricity rate in Southeast Asia, he said.
Samaniego said the government has been studying remedies to lower its power cost and the goal was to power up Philippine industries using renewable energy. /cb