Duterte lawyers raise concerns over prosecution microsite

MANILA, Philippines — The defense lawyers of former President Rodrigo Duterte at the International Criminal Court (ICC) are calling for the stricter authentication of prosecution evidence that came from open source materials, as his trial for alleged crimes against humanity draws near.
According to a document released on Friday, Peter Haynes, Duterte’s lead counsel, asked the ICC’s Trial Chamber III to amend the “E-Court Protocol,” the court’s electronic system, by adding an “expert verification field” for the listing of items to be cited as evidence.
The move was made ahead of the trial which starts Nov. 30.
READ: ICC prosecution submits witness list, evidence vs Duterte
‘New challenge’
Haynes noted that the microsite created by the Office of the Prosecutor (OTP), called “OTPLink” with the URL appeals.icc-cpi.int, for the anonymous submission of materials created a “new challenge” for the defense as it was supposedly vulnerable to tampering.
The prosecution launched the microsite in December 2024 to call for more witnesses and more documentary evidence when Duterte’s case was still at the pretrial stage. It encourages past and present police officers and other members of law enforcement agencies to come forward virtually and help in the investigation of the killings during Duterte’s war on drugs.
READ: Duterte ICC case: Nearly 7,000 evidence items disclosed ahead of trial
“There is also the obvious danger that nefarious actors will use the system to transmit falsified, manipulated, or forged evidence, which might also be circulated online; a risk identified by the Office of the Prosecutor itself,” the defense said in the document dated Aug. 31.
“[W]ith three months until the start of trial, the defense is deeply concerned that the quality and quantity of the evidence in this case risks flooding the record with unreliable and/or irrelevant material. This would be detrimental for the parties and the chamber’s search for the truth, and reputationally damaging for the court,” it noted.
The prosecution, defense and the legal representatives for victims initially agreed to add a “URL” field to identify materials from open sources, which could not be easily attributed to a witness.
But the defense argued that merely providing the URL of an “open source evidence” is not enough to prove its authenticity and avert the risk of collecting false information, adding: “The URL merely records the web location from which a piece of online content was collected; it cannot indicate its source.”
“Aside from the limitations as to what can be inferred about the source from a URL, it further says nothing of: the discovery process, which is vital to confirm its chain of custody; whether an item has been edited in any way; whether the content featured at that URL has been independently verified; whether AI (artificial intelligence) tools were used to filter the evidence, and whether there are any other indicia of authenticity and reliability,” it added.
As a remedy, the defense wants “expert verification reports” alongside the crowdsourced items to indicate information on the source, whether sender or creator if known; its chain of custody and whether it is original or a copy; its metadata, time of capture and other technical details; the steps taken to verify the information; as well as the qualifications and experience of the person who vetted the information.
“Without this information, it would be very difficult for the chamber to come to a view on the evidence’s relevance and admissibility,” it said.
The defense cited the OTP’s annual reports that more than 570,000 electronics had been collected from the microsite as of 2025 to point out the voluminous nature of the materials being gathered by the prosecution.
“Since the first status conference in this case, the prosecution has been on notice that the Trial Chamber wishes to avoid ‘unnecessary and irrelevant evidence’ being ‘dumped into the court record’,” it stressed.
This was one of Korner’s reminders to the parties during the first status conference in May to prevent a “wholesale” of documentary evidence that are deemed not useful to the case.
Based on disclosures publicly available, the prosecution has turned over nearly 7,000 pieces of evidence to the legal team of Duterte in the first seven months of the year. But according to the defense, in its latest filing, more than 25,000 items have been disclosed, with more expected to come.
The latest request by Duterte’s lawyers comes after they also urged the TC III to order the prosecution to amend the scope of the charges in terms of counts for a “more defined scope” of the crimes under the jurisdiction of the ICC.
They also asked for an exhaustive list of “underpinning acts which represent the entirety of the charges against the accused.” Duterte, who is detained in the Scheveningen prison complex in The Hague, is accused of three counts of murder as a crime against humanity in connection with the deaths of 76 people from 2013 to 2018. /cb