ICC prosecution opposes Duterte bid to skip confirmation hearing
This report is part of Inquirer’s special coverage of Duterte at the ICC. For real-time updates, follow our live coverage of the confirmation hearing.

Updated Feb. 20, 5:35 pm
MANILA, Philippines — The International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecution has opposed former president Rodrigo Duterte’s request to waive his right to appear at the confirmation hearing, saying there’s no reasonable cause for him not to appear in person in court.
In a six-paged filing dated Feb. 19, Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang argued that the former president, in his request, failed to provide any compelling reason that would justify the confirmation hearing being held in his absence.
“Mr. Duterte primarily seeks to waive his right to appear on the basis that he does not ‘recognize the jurisdiction’ of the Court, states that he was ‘kidnapped’, and claims that the charges against him constitute ‘an outrageous lie’ invented by his political opponents. These statements are a continuation of Mr. Duterte’s rejection of the legitimacy of the proceedings against him before the Court,” the filing reads.
“His refusal to acknowledge the legitimacy of the proceedings does not constitute cause to hold the confirmation hearing in his absence,” it emphasizes.
Niang then underscored that Duterte is fit, competent, and physically and mentally able to attend the hearing in person, adding that his health has been comprehensively examined and litigated before the chamber.
“To this end, the Chamber has concluded that he is both physically and mentally fit to participate in the confirmation proceedings, and has put measures in place to ensure his comfort throughout the hearing,” the prosecution noted.
“It has done so with the benefit of extensive independent medical evidence and expert opinion. As such, Mr Duterte’s complaints that he is ‘old, tired, and frail’ are irrelevant,” it pointed out.
READ: Duterte to skip ICC hearing, refuses to recognize its jurisdiction
Niang likewise argued that the fact that Duterte does “not wish to attend” should be given minimal weight in the Chamber’s decision on this matter, saying that general health concerns alleged by Duterte have been fully considered and accommodated by the chamber as necessary, and cannot now be recycled as cause to hold the confirmation hearing in his absence.
“In addition, the fact that Mr. Duterte has stated that he will not even follow the proceedings via video link demonstrates that his reasons to avoid appearing in public are not health related but rather due to his lack of respect for the Court,” the filing further states.
With this, the Prosecution is requesting that the chamber reject Duterte’s request to waive his right to appear at the confirmation hearing scheduled to open on Feb. 23.
In a text message to the Inquirer on Friday afternoon, Duterte’s lead counsel, Atty. Nicholas Kaufman, said the law entitles the former president to present a waiver, and so he did.
“The Prosecution has not encountered a situation like this previously, and it clearly conveys in its filing its irritation and belief that it is not the former president who should be controlling the narrative,” he said in response to the prosecution’s comment on the waiver.
Kaufman also explained that Duterte has never recognized the ICC’s jurisdiction over him and that, as of the date of his waiver, the matter is still “awaiting an appeals judgment.”
“For this reason, there are no grounds to reproach him. Accordingly, the judges will now have to decide whether to compel the former President’s appearance and how that should be enforced,” he said.
Meanwhile, Sen. Robin Padilla, a known Duterte ally, also took a jab at ICC prosecutors, asking whether they were really studying law.
Padilla said it is within an accused’s rights to waive the right to appear before the court.
“It’s the accused’s right. I thought this prosecution was… are you even studying law? It’s the accused’s right if he doesn’t want to appear, especially since he is already old. That is his right — human rights,” he said in Filipino.
“He can use all kinds of laws to avoid appearing there, especially here in our country, the Philippines — or when you see him again, you’ll say that Digong looks old and turn it into a joke, oh my. We already know that. It is the right of our former president to say that he does not want to appear,” he added.
The confirmation of charges hearing will be held until Feb. 27.
After this, the ICC said within 60 calendar days following the hearing, the judges will make a decision on whether or not to confirm all or any of the charges brought against Duterte by the prosecutor.
If one or more charges are confirmed, the suspect is then considered an accused, and the case is committed for trial before a Trial Chamber.
Duterte is suspected of the crimes against humanity of murder and attempted murder, allegedly committed on the territory of the Philippines between Nov. 1, 2011 and March 16, 2019 in the context of his so-called “war on drugs” campaign.
According to the Prosecution’s submission of the Document Containing the Charges, Duterte is suspected of the following 3 counts of crimes against humanity:
- Murders in or around Davao City during the Mayoral period by the Davao Death Squad
- Murders of High-Value Targets during the Presidential period
- Murders and attempted murders in barangay clearance operations during the Presidential period /das/mcm