Longhorn Saloon in Scenic, South Dakota is still adorned with cattle skulls and emblazoned with the building's founding date of 1906. The city was recently sold by ailing owner Twila Merril to Iglesia ni Cristo, a Filipino church whose intentions are a complete mystery to area residents. AP
SCENIC, South Dakota—The saloon is long empty. The roadside jail cells, rusted and worn. Even the swing sets peek from behind knee-high brush after decades of neglect.
This tiny territory just west of South Dakota’s badlands is officially an old ghost town. But its future is shrouded in new mystery.
“We don’t know what’s coming,” said Kathy Jobgen, 50, the only employee remaining at the only business still in town—the US Post Office.
The town of Scenic—once a popular stop for people traveling to Rapid City from the badlands to the east or Pine Ridge Reservation to the south—was recently purchased by an unusual buyer for less than $800,000.
The Iglesia ni Cristo (INC), a religious sect established in the Philippines in 1914, bought the town and surrounding acreage from longtime resident and area rodeo legend Twila Merrill, who had gathered the land bit by bit over several decades.
The so-called Church of Christ isn’t divulging its plans for the property. A person answering the phone at the INC office in Daly City, California, said he couldn’t share any information, as did staffers of INC spokesperson Bienvenido Santiago.
“They’ve got a nondisclosure agreement, and I’m a signatory to that,” said David Olsen, the real estate agent who represented Merrill’s family in the sale.
The agent only offered bits of detail—the saloon and other boarded-up buildings still standing along Main Street will stay—but he said he couldn’t give specifics.
“The gas station will be open for business again soon enough,” said Olsen, of Coldwell Banker in Rapid City. The buyers of the property are “interested in it being a benefit to the community,” he added.
Steadily spreading
The Iglesia ni Cristo has been steadily spreading west since it was founded in the Philippines by Felix Manalo, a former minister of the Seventh-Day Adventist Church who experienced what he claimed to be a call similar to those of ancient prophets. He died in 1963.
Often described as one of the fastest-spreading international religions, the Philippine-based sect has grown from about 1.4 million followers in 1990 to 1.7 million in 2000, according to the 2011 figures released by the National Statistics Office in Manila.
The Iglesia ni Cristo rejects the Christian doctrine of trinity and believes Christ is one of several prophets. The church is focused on the end times, believes Manalo is a prophet and considers the Catholic Church apostate.
The sect has a divisive reputation. It’s backing has been viewed as crucial in Philippine national and local elections, and it has been accused of organizing bloc voting in that country. It also is known for its secrecy, rarely commenting on its activities.
Lack of information
So far, there has been no INC activity in Scenic to hint at what’s to come—no construction permits have been sought nor have any development plans been presented to the county.
The lack of information surrounding the sale has some neighbors uneasy, and rumors are circulating among the scattering of residents.
“They bought it sight unseen,” said Shirley Kudrna, whose father-in-law was born on a ranch about 11 kilometers east of Scenic in 1916.
“Some people say maybe they’re a cult,” said Shirley’s father-in-law, Tony Kudrna, 95, who has lived on the ranch nearly his whole life.
5,600 congregations
The Iglesia ni Cristo has expanded to more than 5,000 congregations in the Philippines, and more than 600 abroad in more than 60 countries and territories, according to newspaper reports.
The religious sect has held neighborhood events to praise the hospitality of the communities where it has purchased land to build homes and churches, including Los Angeles, Orlando, and Union County, New Jersey.
Other congregations are established in more than 40 American states, according to the sect’s website. Dozens are listed in California, 10 in Washington state, 12 in Texas and seven in New York.
Good neighbor
Jobgen said she was hopeful the church would make for a good neighbor.
“I’m excited about the possibilities,” said Jobgen, who also runs the Jobgen Ranch with her husband.
The intersection of flourishing religion and foundering town is perplexing: In 1915, the state Highway 44 pit stop of Scenic enjoyed its largest population of 155 residents, according to records kept by the South Dakota State Historical Society.
Pure Old West
At its peak, the town that’s pure Old West had two restaurants, three gas stations, two bulk filling stations, a hotel, a school, a bank and a post office.
Tony Kudrna recalled that his sister worked at one of the restaurants. To travel from his homestead to the comparatively bustling town, he went by horse-drawn wagon.
The remnants still dot the 5 hectares that qualify as deserted town.
The buildings that remain are padlocked closed and have plywood over their windows and doors, but the flavor of the time is still very much present: The sign above the Longhorn Saloon is lined with aged cattle skulls and emblazoned with the structure’s year of construction—1906.
The wooden general store is adorned with rusted wagon wheels and a carved sign that reads: “ASHES TO ASHES—DUST TO DUST—IF WE DON’T HAVE IT—IT ISN’T A MUST.”
Cancer prompts sale
Merrill, a rancher and rodeo regular, began buying Scenic property in 1963. Olsen said Merrill’s health began to fail about two years ago, and as cancer took hold, she was forced to put the land—19 hectares in total—on the market.
The property languished for two years with a $3-million price tag. In July, Olsen stepped in and dropped the cost to $799,000.
Prospective buyers suddenly stepped forward from all over the world, according to Olsen.
The real estate agent estimated he must have taken more than 500 phone calls and 200 e-mails about the property. He also appeared on television programs in Australia, London, Montreal, Chicago and Atlanta.
The offer from the Iglesia ni Cristo was one of several.
“It was Twila’s decision as to whom she chose,” Olsen said. “She seems to be real happy with it.”
So what’s next?
What happens next is not known publicly.
Olsen said the property would be cleaned of dilapidated buildings and overgrown brush, but he said the buildings at the town’s heart would remain.
Not even Merrill and her family know more than that, he said.
“They do not know the plans,” Olson said. “They’re as eager as everybody else.” AP