New senators, bishop voice concern over bases access plan


Sen. Jose Victor “JV” Ejercito INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines—Malacañang must first secure a commitment from the United States and other allies that they are prepared to defend the Philippines from external threats before the Senate considers an agreement that would allow foreign troops access to military bases in the country, junior senators said on Wednesday.

The Palace should also ensure that the Philippines does not end up under foreign control by giving access to foreign troops to its military bases, a Catholic Church official said.

Sen. Jose Victor “JV” Ejercito said Palace officials should have taken their cue from last year’s experience when no ally came to the country’s defense as Chinese vessels encircled and intimidated Philippine fishing boats at Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal, a rich fishing ground well within Philippine waters.

“We have seen during the height of tensions we had with China, we did not feel the support of Big Brother… We felt they were not really there to back us when China was bullying us,” Ejercito said, referring to the United States.

The Philippines and the United States have forged a Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA) that allows temporary presence of US forces in the country.

The agreement is invoked whenever joint military exercises between US forces and Philippine troops are staged, but never when China throws its weight around in the West Philippine (South China) Sea to intimidate the Philippines.

Allies’ support

“I think one of the provisions or conditions of the VFA is that if one ally is in conflict with others, the other one would support (it),” Ejercito said in an interview with the Inquirer.

Apart from reviewing the VFA, Ejercito said, the government must also “get a commitment from the US to fulfill (its) obligation to help (its) Little Brother.”

Other junior senators also cautioned parties planning the access agreement to first make sure to clarify the meaning and scope of any temporary stay that would be granted to foreign forces.

“Is temporary one year, two, 10 or 25 years?” Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino IV asked in an impromptu news conference at the Senate press office.

In a talk with reporters on Tuesday, President Aquino indicated he wanted to give the United States and Japan access to the former US bases in the Philippines so as to forge a “credible alliance” with them.

Aquino also dismissed China’s accusation that Manila was provoking Beijing by allowing foreign troops in its territory.

Not permanent

Ejercito said he did not believe granting the soldiers of foreign allies temporary access to Philippine military bases would be a problem.

“As long as we do not give them a permanent facility. I think it would just be in line with the VFA, which does not say it’s prohibited as long as it’s not permanent,” Ejercito said.

“Admittedly, we cannot defend ourselves from external aggression… The reason we favored the VFA before was that (US forces) would aid us in case the Philippines [faced an external threat],” Ejercito said.

Senator Aquino stressed that the Senate voted to reject a new military bases agreement with the United States in 1991, forcing American troops to leave Subic Naval Base in Zambales province and Clark Air Base in Pampanga province.

“Let’s not bring them back,” Aquino said.

“Of course, visiting forces are another matter. I think we should keep it at the level of visiting forces, but not for us to have another base and for them to stay here again,” he added.

“The period for bases is probably over. But on the issue of looking for partnerships or support, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that… Probably we can keep it to that level first and let’s see,” Aquino said.

In separate interviews, two other junior senators—Juan Edgardo Angara and Nancy Binay—said guidelines such as the length of stay of any foreign force must be carefully studied before the Philippines entered into any access agreement with its allies.

Foreign control

Also on Wednesday, retired Caloocan Bishop Deogracias Iñiguez, chairman of the Public Affairs Committee of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP), said the Aquino administration should make sure that allowing American and Japanese troops into the country will not violate Philippine sovereignty.

Iñiguez said granting foreign forces access to former US bases here should not lead to the Philippines coming under the influence or control of foreign powers.

Iñiguez said the Catholic Church would not keep quiet if it saw that the government’s decision would affect the country’s sovereignty.

“We need to maintain good relations with other countries, but we should see to it that this will not lead to them holding us by the neck,” Iñiguez said in an interview.

“To the extent that we become under them, that’s the bad thing. This (access plan) might be used to do that,” he added.

Iñiguez urged Congress to thoroughly investigate the details of President Aquino’s plan to open the country’s military bases to American and Japanese forces as tensions increase between the Philippines and China over territorial disputes in the West Philippine Sea.

“That is one of the competencies that our legislators and government officials should ask. Now, the Church will go into that when there are moral issues like colonialism and imperialism,” Iñiguez said.

“If that happens, we will certainly speak out because that is a moral violation of [our sovereignty],” he added.



Iñiguez said that while the Philippine government “should be open to other countries,” it should try to foresee the consequences of allowing foreign troops access to the country’s military bases.

“We have to study this very well to determine what is really good for the country,” he said.

When asked if the “bullying” by China should be considered, Iñiguez said: “We are a member of an international family and part of that is having proper relations and coordination with another country. I think there are many other means to deal with bullying.”—With a report from Philip C. Tubeza

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • kangsongdaeguk

    “Iñiguez said the Catholic Church would not keep quiet if it saw that the government’s decision would affect the country’s sovereignty.”
    Yeah, as if the catholic church (lowercase intended as a sign of disrespect!) does not “affect the country’s sovereignty.”

  • opinyonlangpo

    Or rather the congress should investigate those people who are apparently against defending the Philippines. Like those who are opposing to the defense contingencies of the government, the base access of foreign forces. “Iniguez thinks” there are other ways to deal with bullying but can’t present another option. These people are paranoid about the Philippine allies but can’t say a thing against China.

  • rburke

    let’s make base in Panatag shoal and see if the GI Joes will be there with us..

  • Patikotiko

    Senators should voluntarily give 50% of their pork barrel to the military to buy missile, patrol boats and high powered machine guns, so they can patrol and protect our territorial waters. US and Japan will help us but to a certain limits. We need to be prepared for the worst.

  • freedom of navigation

    The US has assured us plenty of times that they will honor their 1951 treaty with us in case our country is attacked. The most recent assurance is from a top defense official not from a gossip.

  • skyla

    lets give them a break. gusto magsalita kasi bago sila sa senado at least may naginterview na sa kanila hehe.

  • gikiness

    dapat mas mabahala kayo sa sobrang pagkaagresibo ng china

  • ctalento

    These people probably do not appreciate the gravity of the situation. Perhaps they should ferry themselves to the disputed areas on board our outdated vessels, or better yet, on board our fishermen’s boats so that they would realize and understand the need for such a move.

    The VFA is only effective for training of our troops but it does not bolster the capability of our defense in the sense that they are not contributing to our equipment. The bases on the other hand are a strategic and actual move to defend our country by allowing much more capable allies to stand against external aggressors.

  • lex

    Father, ang dami mong sinsasabi pero ng tanungin ka tungkol sa pang bu BULLY ng China, iba ang sagot mo, ” member ng international family ” ,CHURCH na lang asikasuhin mo, wag ka ng UMEPAL dito!

  • pololoy

    “When asked if the “bullying” by China should be considered, Iñiguez said ‘…… I think there are many other means to deal with bullying.’ ”

    Can you please cite one example of your “other means to deal with bullying”, Bishop?

    Or do you mean, we run to the school teachers when bullied by china?

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks




latest videos