US can detect fake PH immigration arrival-departure stamps


Vivian has been a permanent resident of the United States since 1999. She lives with her children. A few months after she was diagnosed with an illness, Vivian decided to return to the Philippines.  She stayed in her hometown for more than two years where she eventually recovered. She then decided to return to the US to reunite with her son.

Vivian was worried that her lengthy stay would affect her green card status. So she approached a man who was introduced to her as having “connections” to Philippine immigration officials.  In order to conceal her length of stay in the Philippines, the man told Vivian he could place a stamp on her passport to indicate that she stayed outside the US for less than six months. Vivian agreed to a deal and gave him her passport.

After a few days, Vivian’s passport was returned to her with what looked like an official Philippine immigration stamp showing a false arrival and departure date in the Philippines. The stamp indicated that she stayed only for a few months.

Caught at the airport

Vivian returned to the US last month and presented her passport to  the US immigration inspector. She was taken to secondary inspection where she was questioned more extensively on the dates stamped on her passport. She was warned prior to answering questions that she could be prosecuted for perjury regarding false testimony and may face a fine or imprisonment. Vivian eventually gave in and admitted the truth to the US immigration inspector. She cried and begged to be released and allowed to enter the US.

The immigration inspector asked Vivian to sign her written testimony. She had spent more than five hours at the secondary inspection office and was handed a notice to appear at a deportation hearing. She was given a temporary permit to enter the US but would face charges of fraudulently presenting a falsified document to gain entry to the US.

Will the immigration judge take away Vivian’s green card and send her back to the Philippines?

Seeking admission

A noncitizen seeking entry into the US must have a valid visa and travel document. Those who are non-green card holders may be refused entry at the airport.

Unlike nonimmigrants, green card holders like Vivian may not be subject to expedited airport-to-airport removal. She will be asked to leave only if she voluntarily signs an “abandonment” of permanent resident status at the port of entry. It is possible to request  temporary entry on parole to be allowed temporary entry. Such entrants can exercise their right to a hearing in order to defend  their immigration status or get new visas.

Fraud and willful misrepresentation is a basis for refusal of entry or removal from the US. The initial findings of fraud by the US immigration inspector may be contested in an immigration court. Unfortunately, there are those who are fearful and decide to give up their green card immediately, including their right to a hearing.

Warning  vs fraud

The US Department of Homeland Security maintains a database that easily detects actual dates of travel of those entering and departing the US. Backdating will only cause more harm than good.

At best, an individual who plans to stay in the Philippines for a lengthy period of time must plan on getting a reentry visa prior to departing the US. If  the extended stay in the Philippine was not really planned but was due to circumstances beyond the control of the green card holder, obtaining a returning resident visa at the US Embassy in Manila is a better option than falsifying passport stamps. Backdating just does not work.

(Tancinco may be reached at or at 887 7177 or at 721


Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • mangtom

    PurpleDaisy13: While the visa application process is rigid, still there are people who fall through the cracks. And that is where the INS agents come in at the port of entry or border.  Sometimes the subjects are selected if they do not pass the system of profiling. These agents are trained to spot  the behavior of these people. Diyan sila nadadali. Kaya ang title nitong article ay tungkul sa fake arrival at departure.

    • PurpleDaisy13


      re: “While the visa application process is rigid, still there are people who fall through the cracks.”

      these are random selections. just as citizens at airports are also randomly inspected upon boarding…there’s nothing to be worried about with random selections unless you know you’re guilty of something.

      re: “These agents are trained to spot  the behavior of these people.”

      yes, they are trained to compare the info stamped on your passport against the info in their database. if they don’t match, they’ll use their training to entertain your behavior of how you lie so they’ll know how to spot it instantly in the future.

      re: “Kaya ang title nitong article ay tungkul sa fake arrival at departure.”

      yes, the title is fake arrival at departure because that’s exactly what the woman resorted to. she simply paid an illegal underground forgery service to press a stamp onto her passport to reflect her desired dates but little did she know that the stamp does not imply that such record would be updated in the US database system. that’s an automatic red flag for any immigration agent at the counter.

  • anony mous

    Well a classic example of how stupid Filipinos are. 

  • southernsons

    an example of Filipino traits who likes to shortcut/fake everything just to get the job done.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks




latest videos