Quantcast
Latest Stories

US judge says Filipino teachers’ case falls under human trafficking law

By

Ingrid Cruz, Filipina robotics teacher in Baton Rouge. A federal judge has ruled the conditions that Filipino teachers were subjected to when brought to Louisiana qualifies their case to be heard under the federal human trafficking law.

BATON ROUGE — A Los Angeles federal judge has ruled that the conditions that Filipino teachers were subjected to when brought to Louisiana qualifies their case to be heard under the federal human trafficking law.

According to DailyWorld.com, US District Judge John A. Kronstadt’s ruling is the first time the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA) would be applied to a class of people, instead of individuals.

The Alabama-based Southern Poverty Law Center filed the lawsuit, on behalf of Filipino teachers, against the East Baton Rouge Parish Board (EBRSB), primarily the superintendent’s office.

Also involved are the companies the school board worked with, based in Manila and Los Angeles. An official in the EBRSB superintendent’s office facilitated the importation of teachers and conducted interviews in Manila.

Steve Monaghan, president of the Louisiana Federation of Teachers, which brought the teachers’ plight to light, said Tuesday “I’m not proud that we had to deal with this in Louisiana.

“I am proud that that we seemed to kick the ball off to get redress for these teachers,” he said. “Aiding in the pursuit of justice makes me quite proud.”

Starting in 2007, more than 350 Filipino teachers were brought to Louisiana to fill vacancies in several school districts across the state. Filipino teachers also were brought into the US for positions in other states but only the Louisiana teachers filed suit over their treatment.

They had to pay exorbitant fees, by Filipino standards, to get here and were required to relinquish a portion of their salaries to companies that recruited them and arranged transportation and work visas. They paid high interest rates to the lender the company required them to use.

The teachers testified in a Louisiana Workforce Development hearing that went in their favor that they were crowded into apartments and charged more than the rent charged the other tenants. They were told who they could communicate with. They also could not leave the US because the companies confiscated their passports until they paid the assessments.

The federal lawsuit, Nunag Tanedo v. East Baton Rouge Parish School Board, was filed in August 2010. The teachers are represented by the Southern Poverty Law Center, the American Federation of Teachers and the law firm of Covington & Burling LLP.

A trial is scheduled in July.

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: education , Filipino , Human trafficking , Overseas employment , United States

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.
  • http://twitter.com/Swanee1 Kel Marlow

    Great to see action being taken to prosecute these people responsible for this. Anyone who takes advantage of others because of their poor financial situation should be ashamed, and prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

  • http://twitter.com/sandpiper64 tim_batang4

    This is how democracy works. THE COURTS interpret the law, not the executive, not the legislative, and certainly not any of the boards and district offices under the executive or the legislative.
    The law may not always be interpreted correctly, but the challenges go up the ladder of the judicial branch, and the buck ends at the feet of Supreme Court judges, and what THEY say is the final interpretation of the law, no matter how the executive or the legislative branches feel.
    Learn from this, Pnoy.

  • OFW Franklin

    cheers to Steve Monaghan for his duty care to the plight of Filipino teachers. Boooo to East Baton Rouge Parish School Board for not adhering to their code of ethics and treating FIlipino as number and not as person…..

  • Anonymous

    diko alam ang aking reaction
    kung ma shock ako or magalit or mainis or ano
    grabe ano?
    sa U.S. pa nangyari
    na revive ang slavery na akala ko pina abolish na sa panahon ni Pres Abe Lincoln.
    naawa ako sa kababayan nating nadenggoy
    kung sino man ang Recruiter nian, dapat managot

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TAFVA5LSGQ32CVNIPT5DYIKLEY Dan

    Anywhere there are bad people (even Church officials take advantage of the innocents – only in PH they are good in covering it because of our culture). The US have a law to punish them and the law in the US works as written, else their SC will translate it and they are satisfied with the interpretation. Compare to PH our law is not clear (I believe it was intentionally written vague) that is why those who can hire expensive lawyers can get around with our law. Also even our SC (before Corona) translate it, there are other sectors who come out with their own interpretation. Senators and Congressmen who have large number of bill submitted/passed is just making papogi to keep them in power and those bills are popular at that time but later there will be a lot of problem and the people suffers (quality is better than quantity – there are many hidden agenda in quantity, overall is no good).

  • Anonymous

    i commend him too

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YZXXKB3KBPLB4RXFUSHFFCNRQM Fr. Flo'

    I was just wondering how your comment included this phrase: ”
    even Church officials take advantage of the innocents
    - only in PH they are good in covering it because of our culture  …”   How is this related to this article? Is it because this is against 
    East Baton Rouge Parish Board, which has nothing to do with any church at all!  As the definition of parish in the context of the State of Louisiana says: 
     A parish is an administrative subdivision in Louisiana that corresponds to a county in other U.S. states.

  • Anonymous

    Is it in America?

    High apartment rental could happen in Ontario too, immigrants were charged sometimes for 6 months or more upfront and the owner or superintendent of the apartment would say, it is for the benefit of  the immigrant. Any reader who would like to challenge this statement can go to Mississauga and ask few questions to immigrants who arrived in the 90′s and early in the millennium.

    About confiscation of the passports, that could be an idea of an arab descent. Only in Saudi Arabia and other arab countries (what I used to think) are places where passports are confiscated by the employer so that the employee cannot go anywhere (he/she becomes an automatic criminal if he/she leaves his/her employer even if the reason is valid). Basically arabs are worst of the worst kind. The blacks should not have problem with the statement because the arabs were the first successful mariners who raided the coast of africa for slave trade.

    I worked in the US for several years (with TN visa) and I found out that american attitude is generally stupid. I pointed that out to my barber in Tulsa, who was a retired colonel together with his twin brother, that there should be no Bradley Fighting Vehicle but instead a Patton Fighting Vahicle because Gen Bradley was more of an armchair general who was the darling of the politicians during the war. The colonel was honest enough to tell me that he had never thought of that before. [He and his brother enlisted as privates and were both recommended for COC. Both of them were highly decorated but were retired nonetheless by the Army. He was assigned all over the world but not in the Philippines. He and his brother in 2 separate units became Powerpoint aide for their respective commanding general, I can't remember if my barber was with either the "screaming eagle" or the "big red one". He talked fondly of his son who plays soccer and his daughters who were always in their swimming pool learning synchronized swimming].

    I also complained about America’s  (or American’s) fondness for countries (or people) that (who) do not support America’s policies anywhere, anytime, like India and Pakistan. The assistance that America has given to Pakistan was so big as compared to what it gave to the Philippines. Any other nationality can easily go to America but not the Filipinos who are always at America’s authority’s cross-hairs and are promptly deported unlike the others. Tactical airlift planes could not re-fuel in India but through Bill Gates Indians are coming and going in droves in America. In Pakistan, when an earthquake struck, many New York doctors went and volunteered to treat the people in the villages ravaged by the tremor. The doctors became exasperated because they found out that they should carry the injured themselves while the Pakistani men where watching them from afar.

    There was an old fellow who worked with me at EDS who said once that if he decides to go to Manila, he would get 2 mistresses and be protected by paying a policeman some sort of a retainer’s fee. I retorted to him that he cannot do that because he is too old and he is not rich.If he thought that he can insult my people, then he should be ready to be insulted back.One day, I mentioned about an average Filipino’s respect for Americans is partly due to the endearing legacy of General MacArthur. He became agitated that he mentioned about his father’s complaint about MacArthur failure to provide the marines (his father was a sergeant)  air cover during the battle in or somewhere near PNG. According to what his father narrated to him, the tide of the battle was back and forth when MacArthur’s convoy of aircraft passed overhead with fighter escort and ground attack planes but they all went by while marines were dying below. I replied to him, the Marines itself had air support group that whoever was in command letting those men too vulnerable, should be court-martialed. Then he added for a good measure that, “..anyway MacArthur was not a good man, that was the reason why he was relieved of his command”. I replied, “yes, Patton was not a good man and was MacArthur too and also Earps were worse than train robbers, like Jesse James who’s until now young Americans looked up to, Al Capone’s name is more popular than Elliot Ness and that the Kennedy brothers were that abusive and they deserved to die”. His face became so red and I ended my launched break and headed back to our department.

    I can go on and on relating my anecdotal experience with the Americans in the workplace. But the above should be adequate to sufficiently describe their treatment of Filipinos and anyone they consider too ambitious or with “holier- than-thou” attitude.

  • http://twitter.com/riccisan ricci santiago

    very nice, and i agree with you.

  • Anonymous

    Thanks.



Copyright 2011 . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
  1. US suit tags Pagcor execs
  2. Ibuna lawyer: Aleli not Ignacio Arroyo’s legal wife due to technicality
  3. ‘Dirty finger’ gets OFW in trouble
  4. 45-year-old US ship for transfer to Philippine Navy has defects
  5. Manila mayor fires police official over kidnap-extortion of 4 Korean tourists
  6. Government lifts ‘au pair’ ban to Europe
  7. Former Pagcor chief denies getting gifts from Okada
  8. Maid kills Singaporean widow after being called stupid
  9. Why Jeremy Lin matters (and Floyd’s rant doesn’t make sense)
  10. Taiwanese official deported after abusing Filipinos
  1. Ex-PH envoy to Mexico held for concubinage, posts bail
  2. Maid kills Singaporean widow after being called stupid
  3. Why Jeremy Lin matters (and Floyd’s rant doesn’t make sense)
  4. Fight is over Rep. Ignacio Arroyo’s assets, says lawyer
  5. US suit tags Pagcor execs
  6. The trials of Al Capone and CJ Corona
  7. Indian airline official shot dead in Parañaque City
  8. Vatican schedules canonization of Pedro Calungsod
  9. Filipino doctor, wanted in US, now a medical reservist in AFP
  10. Manila antidrug units dissolved after illegal arrest of 4 Koreans
  1. Fight is over Rep. Ignacio Arroyo’s assets, says lawyer
  2. ‘My OFW husband came home a different man’
  3. How hard is it to get a US visa?
  4. Bigger US military role in Philippines sought
  5. Ex-PH envoy to Mexico held for concubinage, posts bail
  6. Smell of decay leads to body of Arab tourist in Manila hotel room
  7. Filipino doctor, wanted in US, now a medical reservist in AFP
  8. Maid kills Singaporean widow after being called stupid
  9. US won’t return bases in PH but welcomes offer of more troops
  10. 3 Russian Navy ships dock in Manila for 3-day visit

News

  • Enrile junks De Lima’s testimony as hearsay
  • Honasan to prosecution: Tell court your plans to avoid ‘unpleasant surprises’
  • Shelling kills 2 Western journalists in Syria
  • Aquino hails Arroyo arraignment
  • Quran burning incites deadly riots in Afghanistan
  • Sports

  • Westbrook, Durant power Thunder past Celtics
  • Jeremy Lin to miss dunk moment but will fill bookshelves
  • Pacquiao ‘embarrassed’ by Mayweather offer
  • Manny Pacquiao swept up in Linsanity
  • Don’t wait for P-Noy to save boxing
  • Lifestyle

  • PF Chang’s first Asian branch opens–to long wait lists
  • ‘Tikuron or tikoy turon’
  • Oriental Citrus Salad, Herb Pan-fried Fish–Mama Maimee, it’s good ol’ comfort food!
  • Burrata Cheese Ravioli, Burger with Foie Gras, ‘snowball tiramisu’–chow time in Hong Kong
  • ‘Udang Goreng Chilli Garam’ (Chili Prawns)–a Peranakan favorite
  • Entertainment

  • Sepia-tinted statuettes? Oscar films look to past
  • ‘Bourne’ star leaves ‘legacy’ in Palace visit
  • Through the years …
  • As Pinoy as the jeepney
  • Modern-day superhero
  • Business

  • Oil prices lower on weak Europe, China data
  • No change in PSE index
  • Again, oil firms up prices
  • PPP schools project attracts 15 firms
  • Surging crude oil prices worry BSP
  • Technology

  • US attorneys general pressure Google on privacy
  • Company sues Apple over iPad name in Shanghai
  • Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom released on bail
  • New York taxis could get iPads—report
  • Google under fire for sidestepping track-blocking software
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, February 23, 2012
  • Wisdom, not legality
  • People power
  • The algorithm of kindness
  • ‘Medicare portability’ for Fil-Ams
  • Global Nation

  • Okay to buy warships but don’t bring US into Spratly dispute
  • Ibuna lawyer: Aleli not Ignacio Arroyo’s legal wife due to technicality
  • Government lifts ‘au pair’ ban to Europe
  • Former Pagcor chief denies getting gifts from Okada
  • DFA presses drive for overseas voting
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2011 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved